Gelato isn’t the Italian word for ice cream; it’s a different kind of frozen dessert. It contains less fat and much less incorporated air, is churned more slowly, and is stored at a warmer temperature. As a result, it’s denser, softer, and more pronounced in flavor, which is also why it melts faster. This is the classic base of milk, cream, egg yolk, and sugar, with a small glass of amaretto or sambuca on the side.

Base: milk and egg yolk4 ingredientsGlass: ice cream coupe
Tall ice cream coupe with a wavy rim on a short stem, filled with scoops of red and pale ice cream and fresh berries
GELATO ✶ MILK AND EGG YOLK ✶ ICE CREAM COUPE ✶ CHURN & SCOOP ✶

The gelato recipe
for your table

How many people?
Ingredients
1 person
125 mlwhole milk, chilled
37.5 mlheavy cream, unwhipped
20 gramsegg yolk, about one egg per serving
32.5 gramssugar, fine granulated sugar
Making gelato: step by step
1

Heat the milk with the cream and half the sugar until steaming and all the sugar has dissolved. There’s no need to let it boil; that only dulls the flavor of the milk. Remove the pan from the heat as soon as it’s ready.

2

Whisk the egg yolks with the remaining sugar, then slowly pour in a splash of hot milk while whisking, so they don’t curdle. Pour the mixture back into the pan and stir over low heat until it thickens slightly and coats the back of a spoon, around 82 degrees.

3

Strain the base into a bowl, let it cool, then chill it for at least four hours. This resting time isn’t a detour: a cold base churns firm faster, and the less time it spends in the machine, the smaller the ice crystals will be.

4

Churn the base in the ice cream maker until thick and glossy, then transfer it to a shallow container with a lid. Freeze it for another two hours, and scoop the gelato into bowls just before serving.

What did you think of this recipe?

One click on a star is enough. If you have something to add, we'll review it before it appears here.

Save this recipe

Send the gelato recipe to your own email so you have it handy when you make it. You'll also get a € 5 discount code when you spend € 50, for the glasses that go with it.

You'll receive the recipe, your discount code and our newsletter with new recipes. You can unsubscribe with one click.

The story

Gelato and ice cream are made from the same ingredients, but they are made differently. Ice cream contains more cream, while gelato contains more milk, which means less fat. The machine in a gelateria also churns more slowly, so less air gets into the mixture; professionals call this air increase overrun. In industrial ice cream, the volume can almost double as a result, while in gelato the increase is much smaller. Less fat and less air make for denser ice cream, where the flavor comes through more directly, because fat masks flavor. Finally, gelato is kept warmer in the display case, around twelve degrees below zero instead of eighteen, making it soft enough to serve with a spatula.

The right glass

A gelateria scoops with a flat spatula rather than an ice cream scoop, which is why gelato sits in the coupe in a wave rather than a ball. That calls for width, not depth. The 32 cl Fortuna below is described as a roomy coupe on a short stem, intended for coupes, sorbets and dame blanche, and able to handle the temperature difference of hot espresso over cold ice cream without a problem. The second is wider and shallower, 28 cl, with a stem that lifts the dessert and room for sauce and nuts alongside the serving. Because gelato melts faster than ice cream, the size matters more than you might think: a coupe that holds four scoops will be half full of liquid after ten minutes. So keep the serving small and put the coupes in the freezer for fifteen minutes before scooping. Smaller sizes are available among the dessert glasses.

Tall coupe with a wavy rim on a short stem, filled with scoops of red and pale ice cream with fresh berries
Our pick 01

Bormioli Rocco Fortuna Ice Cream Glass 32 cl (6 pieces)

€ 58,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Wide, round coupe on a thick stem, filled with a white dessert with red fruit sauce, raspberries and mint
Our pick 02

Royal Leerdam Fun 4 Food Ice Cream Coupe 28 cl Primavera (6 pieces)

€ 25,95per set · fast delivery on business days
The complete set

Both sets together € 84,90.

Shop the set →

The right tools

For gelato, use a bar spoon with a long handle to loosen the cold mixture with a quick stir just before churning, and a zester to grate dark chocolate or toasted pistachio over the coupe. These are the bar tools we use ourselves; you can find everything in our bar tools & cocktail sets.

Trident bar spoon, 30 cm

Stirs the cold mixture to loosen it before it goes into the machine

€ 12,95
Multifunctional zester

Grates chocolate or pistachio over the scooped serving

€ 15,95
Everything you need in one click

Glass set (our pick 01) + 2 bar tools together € 87,85.

Everything in the cart →

What to pour alongside it?

Gelato calls for a small glass, not a large one. A splash of liqueur alongside the dessert coupe or even poured over it works better than a full glass of wine, because the ice cream is already sweet and creamy. Amaretto complements the almond in classic flavors, while sambuca pairs with anise. Each drink page tells you the alcohol percentage, what it tastes like, which cocktails it goes with, and what glass you need.

Bottle of Disaronno Originale 70 cl

types, brands and flavors

Bottle of Disaronno Originale 70 cl

around 28% · almond and apricot kernel

Bottle of Molinari Sambuca 70 cl

around 38% · anise, after dinner

Bottle of Kahlúa 70 cl

around 16% · coffee liqueur from Mexico

Bottle of Pallini Limoncello 70 cl

limoncello, around 26%

Bottle of Baileys Original 70 cl

around 17% · cream and Irish whiskey

Bottle of Alasia Moscato d'Asti 75 cl

sweet and light, low in alcohol

Variations & twists

The milk-to-cream ratio varies by flavor, and with gelato, that’s not a mistake but the recipe. Use this base for fior di latte and hazelnut. For chocolate, leave out the egg yolks and use cocoa and melted chocolate as a binder; otherwise, the mixture will be too rich. In a gelateria, fruit flavors like lemon, strawberry, and mango are made with almost no dairy, using water, sugar, and fruit pulp, which makes them more like sorbet than ice cream. Make pistachio gelato by stirring unsalted pistachio paste into the mixture while it’s still warm. Need more inspiration? Browse more than 100 cocktail recipes.

Serving tip

Put the serving glasses in the freezer fifteen minutes before serving, and take the tub out five minutes beforehand; then the gelato will be just the right consistency for scooping. Scoop it in broad, flat layers with a flat spoon rather than into round balls, as they do in gelato shops. A wafer or a spoonful of toasted nuts adds the contrast the soft mixture needs.

Good to know

What is the difference between gelato and ice cream?

Three things at once. Gelato contains more milk and less cream, so it has less fat. It is churned more slowly, which means less air gets into the mixture. And it is stored at a warmer temperature, around twelve degrees below zero instead of eighteen. Together, these factors make gelato denser, softer, and more pronounced in flavor than ice cream.

What does overrun mean?

Overrun is the technical term for the air whipped into ice cream during churning, expressed as an increase in volume. Industrial ice cream can nearly double in volume this way, while gelato increases much less. That’s why a tub of gelato feels heavier than a tub of ice cream of the same size: it literally contains more ice cream and less air.

Why does gelato melt faster?

Because it is served warmer from the display case and contains less fat. Fat slows melting, and the air in ice cream acts as insulation; gelato has less of both. That’s not a flaw but the price of its texture. So serve small portions in pre-chilled glasses, and scoop only once everyone is seated at the table.

Why is gelato kept in tubs under a lid?

In an Italian gelato shop, the tubs sit flat in the display case, covered with a lid. Covered, the surface doesn’t dry out and the gelato doesn’t absorb odors from neighboring tubs, while a flat tub maintains a much more even temperature than an open mound of piped ice cream. In addition, a flat surface lets the spatula do its job.

What is gelato artigianale?

Artisanal ice cream, usually made in small batches and churned on-site. The word describes how it is made; it is not a quality seal. Industrial ice cream is churned in large batches, often with more air and stabilizers, so it can sit in a freezer for weeks without changing texture.

How long does homemade gelato keep?

Covered in a shallow container, it will keep for about a week. Without stabilizers, the ice crystals continue to grow after that and the mixture becomes grainy, especially if the freezer is opened often. Let it sit for five minutes before scooping, since a home freezer is colder than a display case.

Frequently asked questions

What’s the difference between gelato and ice cream?

Gelato contains less fat and much less incorporated air than regular ice cream, and it’s stored at around twelve degrees below zero instead of eighteen below. As a result, it’s denser, softer, and more intensely flavored, and melts faster in the serving dish.

Do you need an ice cream maker to make gelato?

For this recipe, yes. The mixture needs to churn slowly as it freezes; otherwise, the ice crystals become too large. Without a machine, you can stir the mixture vigorously every half hour for the first hour, but that won’t give you the density of real gelato.

Why is there so little cream in gelato?

Because milk takes center stage. Fat masks flavor, so with less cream you taste the pistachio, hazelnut, or fruit more directly. The cream that is added mainly creates a rounder mouthfeel, not the flavor itself.

What temperature should you store gelato at?

In an ice cream shop, it’s kept at around twelve degrees below zero, while a home freezer is usually set to eighteen below. So leave the tub on the counter for five to ten minutes before scooping; the gelato will then be soft enough to scoop.

Everything for your bar,
at one address

Hospitality-quality glasses, sold in sets. Order today and they’ll arrive soon.

Shop the glasses →