Custard is essentially a custard: milk, egg yolk, and sugar that you thicken by stirring. This happens between 80 and 85 degrees. Above 85 the egg curdles, below 75 it stays thin, and that narrow window is exactly why almost every home recipe adds cornstarch, because then the mixture can boil briefly. For the grown-ups, a small glass of Baileys or Kahlúa goes nicely with it.

Base: milk and egg yolk4 ingredientsGlass: tumbler
Custard recipe in the right glass
CUSTARD ✶ MILK AND EGG YOLK ✶ TUMBLER ✶ STIR & THICKEN ✶

The custard recipe
for your table

How many people?
Ingredients
1 person
250 mlvolle melk, met een half vanillestokje en een snuf zout
2 eidooiersuit verse eieren, losgeklopt met de suiker
20 gramfijne kristalsuiker, iets minder als je hem minder zoet wil
2 theelepelsmaizena, eerst aangelengd met een scheut koude melk
Making custard: step by step
1

Split the half vanilla pod, scrape out the seeds, and put the seeds, pod, milk, and salt together in a pan. Bring the milk almost to a boil and remove it from the heat as soon as steam rises.

2

Whisk the egg yolks with the sugar and stir in the diluted cornstarch. While whisking, pour in a splash of the hot milk so the egg gets used to the heat, then stir the mixture back into the pan.

3

Place the pan over low heat and stir along the bottom with a wooden spoon. The custard thickens between 80 and 85 degrees; above 85 the egg curdles, and below 75 it stays thin. With cornstarch added, the mixture can boil briefly, which is exactly why almost every home recipe uses cornstarch.

4

Pour the custard through a fine sieve into a bowl or straight into the glasses, and press plastic wrap tightly onto the surface so a skin doesn't form. Let it cool, and only assemble it once it's cold, with a layer of yogurt on top.

What did you think of this recipe?

One click on a star is all it takes. If you'd like to add a comment, we'll review it before it appears here.

Save this recipe

Send this custard recipe to your own email so you have it handy when you're ready to make it. You'll also get a € 5 discount code on purchases of € 50 or more, for the glasses to go with it.

You'll receive the recipe, your discount code, and our newsletter with new recipes. You can unsubscribe with one click.

The story

Carton custard belongs in the Dutch fridge just like milk and cheese, which makes homemade custard confusing at first: it's thinner. Carton custard contains thickening agents that keep it thick right up to the last day of its shelf life, and you can't achieve that at home with egg yolks and a spoonful of cornstarch. What you get in return is flavor, because real vanilla in milk does something different from flavoring. The double layer of custard with yogurt on top is a Dutch invention that is rarely understood abroad, and you build it up in a glass.

The right glass

The well-known double layer of custard and yogurt depends on a straight-sided glass, because that keeps the dividing line between yellow and white level; in a footed goblet, the line follows the curve and is barely visible. The tumbler below holds twenty-five centiliters, exactly one serving, and according to the description, the faceted surface of this glass makes the layers especially visible. It is also tempered glass that, according to the description, can go from the freezer to a hot wash, so pre-chilling is no problem. There is also a roomy ice cream dish holding twenty-eight centiliters, intended for custard with fruit or crumble on top. There is no such thing as a proper custard glass; in the Netherlands, the regular tumbler has become one in practice. More glassware for dessert is available at the dessert glasses.

Custard in a faceted 25 cl tumbler with a thick base
Our pick 01

Duralex Picardie tumbler 25 cl (6 pieces)

€ 14,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Empty 28 cl ice cream coupe with a round bowl on a sturdy stem
Our pick 02

Onis Primavera ice cream coupe 28 cl (6 pieces)

€ 25,95per set · fast delivery on business days
Complete set

Both sets together € 40,90.

Shop the combination →

The right tools

For custard, in addition to a glass, you'll need a pan, a wooden spoon and two things that make all the difference: a fine strainer to pour the thickened custard through, leaving any egg lumps behind, and a bar spoon with a long handle to build the layered pour in the glass without smearing the sides. These are the bar tools we use ourselves; find them all in our bar tools & cocktail sets.

Fine cocktail strainer 8 cm

Catches egg lumps so the custard pours smoothly into the glass

€ 11,95
Trident bar spoon 30 cm

Long stem for the layered pour, reaching to the bottom of the glass

€ 12,95
Complete in one click

Glass set (our pick 01) + 2 bar tools together € 39,85.

Everything in the cart →

What to serve with it?

Custard is served in most homes with children around, and then nothing goes with it: a glass of milk or water is enough, and that's no shortcoming. If you have it for dessert after dinner, a small glass of liqueur goes well, for example Baileys with the vanilla version or Kahlúa with the coffee and chocolate version. On each drinks page, you'll find the alcohol percentage, what it tastes like, which cocktails go with it, and what glass you need.

Bottle of Baileys Original 70 cl

cream, coffee and anise

Bottle of Baileys Original 70 cl

around 17% · cream with vanilla custard

Bottle of Kahlúa 70 cl

coffee liqueur · with hopjes and chocolate

Bottle of Molinari Sambuca 70 cl

38 to 42% · anise, in a very small glass

Bottle of Hennessy VSOP 70 cl

around 40% · with chocolate custard

Bottle of Bacardi Carta Blanca 70 cl

around 40% · brown rum with caramel

Bottle of Alasia Moscato d'Asti 75 cl

sweet and light · with fruit custard

Variations & twists

The three flavors everyone knows are vanilla, chocolate, and hopjes. For chocolate custard, melt fifteen grams of dark chocolate per serving into the warm milk and leave out the vanilla; for hopjes custard, dissolve a few hopjes in the milk instead, or add strong coffee with caramel. Make the two-layer version by pouring the chilled custard into a glass and spooning a layer of full-fat yogurt along the side. Looking for more inspiration? Browse over 100 cocktail recipes.

Serving tip

Pour the custard into glasses while it’s still warm and immediately cover the surface with plastic wrap, so it cools without forming a skin and you won’t have to transfer it later. Chill for at least three hours, because warm custard is always thinner than it will be once it’s fully set. Finish the glasses at the table with a layer of fruit or crumbled speculoos biscuits, so they stay crunchy on top instead of sinking in.

Good to know

Why does custard thicken between 80 and 85 degrees?

Because the protein in the yolk coagulates at that temperature, thickening the milk. Stay below it, around 75 degrees, and not enough happens, so the custard remains thin. Go above it, and the egg sets too quickly, leaving you with strands and lumps instead of a smooth mixture.

Why is cornstarch in almost every homemade recipe?

Because cornstarch widens the temperature window. The starch coats the proteins, so the egg is less likely to curdle, which means custard made with cornstarch can boil briefly. This makes the recipe much more forgiving at home than a custard made with egg yolks alone, where you really have to watch the temperature.

How do you prevent a skin forming on custard?

Press plastic wrap tightly onto the surface itself, not over the rim of the bowl. A skin forms when moisture evaporates and the proteins on top dry out; if the wrap touches the custard, that can’t happen. This only works if you do it right away, while the custard is still warm.

Why is homemade custard thinner than packaged custard?

Packaged custard contains additives that keep it thick, from starch to carrageenan. At home, you only have egg yolks and cornstarch. You can get closer by adding an extra half spoonful of cornstarch, but the real difference is the flavor: homemade custard has vanilla, not flavoring.

The custard has curdled. Is there anything I can do?

Immediately remove the pan from the heat and pour the custard through a fine sieve to catch most of the egg lumps. Then briefly whisk it or blend it with a hand blender. It won’t be quite as it should be, but almost no one will notice in a glass topped with a layer of fruit.

How many egg yolks go in a liter?

The classic home recipe uses four egg yolks per liter of milk, with 80 grams of sugar, a vanilla pod and two tablespoons of cornstarch. The recipe above uses two yolks per 250 milliliters, so that custard turns out a little richer. For the classic ratio, halve the number of yolks.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly is custard?

Custard is a thickened dairy dessert made with milk, egg yolk and sugar, essentially the same as a custard. At home, cornstarch is almost always added, so the mixture can come to a boil without the egg curdling. It is eaten cold, from a glass or a bowl.

At what temperature does custard thicken?

Between 80 and 85 degrees. Below 75 degrees, it stays thin, and above 85 degrees, the egg curdles. Adding cornstarch gives you a much wider window, because the custard can briefly come to a boil without going wrong.

What glass should you use for custard?

A clear glass with straight sides that lets a spoon reach the bottom; 250 milliliters is a good size for one serving. If you're making the double layer with yogurt, those straight sides are the whole point: they keep the dividing line between the two layers level.

How do you make layered custard with yogurt?

Let the custard cool completely first, because warm custard will mix with anything you put on top. Pour it into the glass, let it stand for half an hour, then carefully spoon a layer of full-fat yogurt on top using the back of a spoon, working inward along the side.

Everything for your bar,
to one address

Horeca-quality glasses, sold in sets. Order today, delivered quickly.

Shop the glasses →